Places Links:



Take This Warning,
you who would hurt
the creatures of wood,
meadow, and hearth.
Beware the Catwomen,
who follow Artemis.


The Spiraling Cycle
(My Spiritual Home page)
Higher Consciousness
(My Story;The Cat's Story)
(find the secret clicks and the deeper in you will go)
(the blog you are reading now)

Magic Carpet Links
in each Moon

Blog Moon
Places Moon
Social Change Moon
Book Moon

Back to the top of this page

Earth Holidays

"From conception the increase
From increase the swelling
From swelling the thought
From thought the remembrance
From remembrance the consciousness,
the desire..."
---- Maori Creation Chant

Winter Solstice
First Light
Spring Equinox
May Day
Summer Solstice
First Fruits
Autumn Equinox
All Hallows Eve

moon phases

Back to the top of this page

 Favorite Places  

Myth*ing Link

45 million voices Abortion stories

ABA News
Abolish Sport Hunting
Abolish Animal Terrorism
Abolitionist On-line
Abuse tracker
Action for Change networking site for change agents
"Afghanistan` Project"
Animal Liberation Front ALF
(May the Universe Keep Them Safe and Active for they are the finest of us all and they harm no living thing despite what the bosses tell you)
Animal Police
Animals and Politics
Animal in WI Recomended Site
Anti-Slavery International
More animal links on my website under Social Change Moon
American Thinker
American Center for Democracy Libel Tourism and first amendment rights
Art Links Place's Moon - 3rd col
Art that Saves Animals
Arts Wisconsin
Ashes & Snow use mouse on each picture
Art original

Banking on Heaven polygamy video
Beautiful Links
Bees do not Sting
Bees & Wannabes
Best Friends Sanctuary and Resources
Big Poon's Very Best Catnip
Bird Food

C-Span Video Library
CAIDS - Hunters for intelligent alternatives to Chronic Wasting Disease hysteria
Catch the Moon
Center for Feminist Art
The Center for Responsible Lending
Center for Gender Refugee Campaigns
Ceramic Sculpture
Birds View - Creamic Sculptures of Jacqeline Jrolf
"A Libra whose element is air. She makes birds and what is happening to the air (and herself) through birds"
Chicago Women's Liberation Union
Coalition for American Workers Save jobs for citizens. Prevent in and outsourcing jobs.
Compassion Over Killing
Conflict Resolution

Corporate Control of US Democracy
Cosmology 3D
Cows with Guns

Daily Coyote
  New Daily Coyote
New Daily Coyote
Daily Puma
Dhimmi Watch
Donna Hughes

Earth Best Defense
Earth Justice Because the earth needs a good lawyer: recommended site
Eat Well at Veg Web
Equal Pay Act Check out how this site has changed under the BO adm. They have a link to go to the old site. Go to the old site to see then and now – they will keep the old site up for a few more months
Equal Rights Amendment
Equal Pay -after 45 years
ET Vegan
Earth & Sky
Eastern Shore Sanctuary
Enough genocide discussions and reports
Equality 4Women Reference papers for organizing
Exploitation and trafficking in Women (Hughes)
Easy to understand/enviromental Issues

Back to the top of this page

Fact Check
Female Genital Mutilation
Family Court Issues for Feminists – Custody - Abuse
Feminist Literature 1405-2011
Feminist News
Feminist News Service
Feminist Peace Network
Feminist Research
Fight for Free Public Resources
Fixed Star consultations
Flying Elephants Foundation
For Any Soldier
Food Fight
Food Politics
Free the Slaves click on the Blog link
Free US Now Radio
Foster Parrots LTD


Garden Habitat
Galapagos Preservation Society
removal of feral (recommended site)

Genderberg Resource for sexual exploitation activists and researchers
Global aid from US
Great Cards
Green Earth Travelvegetarian travel tours
Greener Choices
Green Energy Policy
Guide to Vegetarian Restaurants & Health Food Stores in USA

Handmade Nation
Documentary for Handmade Nation
Hedge Craft Rae Beth
Hillary's Voice NP Blogroll

Human Trafficking Middle East
    State Dept's Office

Illusion Science
Immigration studies
Inclusive Security
Initiative to Educate Afghan Women
Institute for Inclusive Security
Women's Liberation Globally
Intern'l Museum of Womenwomen's art
Iran and Kurd Women's Rights
Isabella's Closet

Jane Goodall Institute
Jihad Watch
Judy Chicago
Judy Chicago Gallery Art
Jung Personality Test


Law Library free
Law News
Lobby for Animals
Latina Women Human Rights

Mad Cowboy
M.A.R.V. (Milwaukee Area Resources for Vegetarians)
Medicinal Herbs
Military Sexual Assault Response and Prevention
Women Organizing Against Military Sexual Assault
Service Women's Support Network
Military Rape research
Monarch Watch - Grow Milkweed!
Moo Shoes
Moonlady Pages
Muslims Against Sharia

Natural Resources Defense Council
NOW News
The National Women's Law Center
Numbers USA Bi partisan immigration reduction organization

On the Question of Animal Rights
Open Secrets
   Open Rescue
Open Rescue

Opinions You Should Have
Operation Bagdad Pups

Visit Green's profile on Pinterest.
Popvox - TO Follow a Bill in Congress
Prostitution Research & Ed
Prostitution Rescue
PC Organization
Primate Freedom (RECOMMENDED SITE)
PISSD - Personal Injury, Social Security Disability injured and disabled persons mistreated by government and insurance companies
Peaceful Choices
Place Moon alternative energy
Polaris Project anti slavery/trafficking


Refugee Resettlement Watch recommended site
Residential Property Issues
Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.)

Sari Art
Sair Art

Sea Shepherd
Skin Deep check your cosmetics to see how toxic they are to your health
Smoothies Recipes for Smoothies
Spirit of America 100% of your tax-deductible donation goes to these projects initiated by Americans serving abroad
Stateline (News from the States)
Stop Honor Killings
Stray Pet Advocacy

Sexual Offenders
National Sex Offender Registry
Sleepwalking to extinction
Survivors of Clergy Abuse
Wisconsin Sex Offender Register

Track Fed Legislation
Travel Guide (Vegetarian)
Treating Glaucoma
Top Ten Links
Trafficking in Women-International

Understanding Taqiyya
US Constitution

Vegetarian Restaurants in Wisconsin
Vegan Essentials
Vegetarian Meals Delivered
Vegetarian Food Facts
Vegetarian Resource Group
void of course
Vegan Nutrition Podcasts
Sacred hallows-not horror violence

Wiscat, Wisconsin’s union catalog
Enter the term, “women,” 444 entries; books, periodicals, oral history interviews, and manuscript collections.

WI Best Friends (recommended animal rescue site)
Wisconsin Woodland Owners and Lovers
Wild WI
Wild Ones
Wolf Pack Tarot
WOMEN AGAINST FUNDAMENTALISM IN IRAN Support Women Slaves Struggling to Organize in Iran - NOW! Follow the link above to find the website of women organizing behind burqas to bring freedom to Iran
Women in the Muslim World
Women Living Under Muslim Laws
Intern'l Women's Day March 8
Women's Foreign Policy Group
Women's Freedom Forum
Women's History Archives
Women's History Month In 1987, Congress declared March to be Women's History Month
Women's Medical Fund, Inc Assisting Wisconsin women who want but cannot afford abortion - please help
Women’s Studies Librarian’s Office Home of Feminist Collections Journal
Women's Suffrage Day August 26th
Women United
Woodstock Farm Sanctuary
WI Coalition Against Domestic Violence I rarely agree with these liberals who take a great deal of the DV funding
WI Incentives for Renewables and Efficiency
WI Newspapers Forum & Blogs
WI Statutes
WI Vegetarian
WI Veterans Museum
WI Watch Reporters covering the underbelly of policy shaping WI while you are unconscious




Despite the challenges, we were seeing free and democratic Iraq, we were living the hard laboring moment we believe that every one of us has duty towards our beloved country. By our hands, work, thoughts, sacrifice we will build up the new Iraq.

Back to the top of this page

WI Anti Trafficking Law

Before we look at Wi's statues, lets read a checklist of things to look for in anti trafficking legislation.

I Policy Considerations Related to State Statutes

The most important advantage of state anti-trafficking legislation is that it removes the fear/threat of prosecution from the victims and provides advantages for their co-operation in prosecuting the trafficker.

The second major advantage of using trafficking statutes verses regular state statues is that trafficking legislation provides stiffer penalties.

The major disadvantage is the length and cost of the investigation necessary to win convictions. However, states have found ways to do this for drug investigation.

In its Model Trafficking Legislation (MTL), the DOJ has mitigated the advantage victim/witnesses receive by a including a“lack of consent” requirement. In DOJ-MTL victim “consent” absolves traffickers of liability.

“Lack of consent” to exploitation is an necessary proof element in the DOJ model legislation. Therefore, one of the elements prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt under the DOJ-MTL is that illegitimate means were used to gain the victim’s consent/cooperation, namely either force, coercion or fraud.

However, consent should be irrelevant. Because of the 13th amendment to the US constitution, the Fair Labor Standards Act and UN conventions, a person cannot consent to slavery. In the US, it is illegal to use wage or sex slaves . Commercial sex is illegal in most states. Kidnaping/bondage/is unlawful. Individuals cannot contract for illegal activities - no such contract will be upheld. Slavery can only be defined, rejected and criminalized. Requiring lack of consent is unnecessary and blaming the victim.

Prosecution should not be based on the lack of consent or the methods used by the trafficker. DOJ wants to distinguish trafficking from smuggling so they can prosecute or deport the smugglers and their clients.

However consent is not the factor distinguishing smuggling from trafficking - the conditions in which victims are held are the distinguishing factor. That their labor is exploited and they are not free to leave distinguishes trafficking from smuggling.

The law has consistently failed, and treated as criminals, slaves who co-operate with their captors and abusers to survive. Patti Hearst is one example. It will be the job of the advocate to push back against the legal system’s desire to prosecute victims whose oppression it does not yet understand.

The trafficker’s acts, benefits and the ultimate consequence to the slave (bondage, deprivation of liberty, exploitation) should be the only elements needed to convict the trafficker and those who participate and facilitate the trafficking enterprise.
That the traffickers benefit in some way from the illegal sexual or wage services of the victim should be enough to show they are traffickers.

Perhaps it will be necessary to show the fact finder the means traffickers used to hold the victim when describing why the slave could not escape. That is different from the beyond a reasonable doubt standard that elements must reach. Additionally, there are many ways to enslave a person and if “means used”are not an element, the prosecutors can adapt the explanations to the particular circumstances.

Sweden has model language that the US trafficking and related state statutes might consider. Sweden prosecutes pimps, johns and brothel keepers, but not prostitutes, because prostitutes are viewed as victims who are treated as commodities in the sex trade. The Swedes claim that since the Sex Purchase Law was implemented, prostitution is down by 40%. Such claims are hard to verify but the concept is consistent with US studies showing that convictions are hampered because the victims are afraid of prosecution and in the case of immigrants, also deportation and reprisals in the country of origin. ( See: Sept. 2008, Sex Trafficking Needs Assessment for the State of Minnesota by The Advocates for Human Rights)

Policy makers in the US need to pay closer attention to Sweden’s statute rather than tinkering endlessly with language that ultimately is just a sexist, racist and classist assumption of free choice consent to slavery. Trafficking penalties however should remain stronger than Sweden’s sanctions. (

Amending the original Trafficking Victims Protection Act, the House of Representatives’ William Wilberforce Act H.R.3887, properly makes the “means used” ( fraud coercion or force) penalty enhancers rather than elements of the crime. However, in response to H.R.3887, then Senator Biden introduced S.3061 which retains the force, coercion, fraud language.

The DOJ model and its’ proof of non consent requirement has infected state statutes and threatened the efficacy of many state trafficking statutes.

To end commercial sex exploitation and economic exploitation advocates must carefully scrutinize state statues and cleanse them of the DOJ virus.

If the senate rejects the Biden Bill, the House Wilberforce Act H.R.3887 will force DOJ to rewrite the Model anyway. Hopefully that will justify the revision of state statutes already passed.
It is important that our state senators are made aware that significant numbers of the electorate want them to pass a bill that does not change H.R.3887' treatment of consent.

There are a few provisions in Biden's Bill that enhance the ability to prosecute and these could be the compromise between the 2 bills. The House could accept:
Sec 22)requires pretrial detention - adds conspiracy and obstruction as possible charges,
Sec 203)requiring written employee contracts for foreign workers and time for complaints to be resolved before deportation is attempted.
Sec )waves filing fees for T Visa, U Visa and VAWA Self Petitions
Sec 232) requires an audit of Defense contractors re trafficking

Advocacy Checklist

When state advocates analyze proposed state anti-trafficking laws, check for the following:
1. Strict Liability
Under 18 - Knowledge of age should not be an element of the crime or an affirmative defense when the victim is under 18. So say the federal appeals courts in the 2nd, 3rd , 4th, 6th, 9th and 10th circuits. Knowledge should be the trafficker’s responsibility.
Nor should there be a proof requirement that the trafficker has knowledge that the victim is being trafficked
All that should be necessary for conviction is that the victim is under 18, the trafficker is benefitting and the victim is exploited. Strict liability should be the norm for crimes against children.

Over 18 - The prosecutor should not have to prove that the trafficker knows the victim is being trafficked. Lack of knowledge should be the defendant’s proof burden when the victims are
over 18.

2. “By Means of” Test: The law should criminalize sex trafficking without any mitigating behavior on the part of the victim. Because of the DOJ model, at this time most state legislation will require some proof of “means used” as an element to show lack of consent (force, coercion, fraud). Advocates should oppose “means used” in proposed legislation. Use the House Wilberforce Act which removed the “means test” as justification for removal in state statutes. Your opponent will be the Defense Bar and the ACLU.

3. Debt bondage: Look for the conditions of labor/ services and its definitions. Labor services involves the deprivation of liberty because of unreasonable terms and conditions. The term debt bondage should be included. Debt should not be a defense to economic exploitation. Remember not all traffickers receive cash but some demand services in exchange for food and shelter. Make sure the definitions use the Model’s for debt bondage and payment is not limited to cash exchanges but is “anything of value”.

4. Commercial Sex Labor or Services: Advocates often oppose the use of this term. Yet it is the term that does not limit sexual commerce to prostitution. Sex trafficking should include more acts than prostitution or sexual contact. Soliciting victims for pornography, strip clubs and massage parlors should also be included or at least prosecution allowed under the elements and definitions. Therefore, if the definition of this phrase includes trafficking for work in pornography, strip clubs and massage parlors and/or prostitution (sexual contact) it is preferable to the narrower language of “commercial sex acts” which is limited to sexual contact. If the phrase “Commercial Sex Labor or Services” language is too offensive then the phrase “sexually explicit performances” can be added to “commercial sex act” for a comprehensive definition of trafficking for sexual exploitation.

5. Penalty Enhancers: Fraud, force or coercion, along with all other methods of dominating the victim should enhance the punishment not be an element of the offense. The act of enslavement, economic or sexual, should be per se an offense unrelient on the complaint of the victim. Lack of Knowledge if proved by the defendant can mitigate the penalty.

6. Resource Funding: Statute should contain data collection funding and the establishment of a state Trafficking Enforcement Unit in the state Dept of Justice. Statue should contain training, consultant and convention funds, especially for legal system professionals and advocates. Training can be part of continuing legal education requirements. Look for funds for a Public Awareness Campaign.

Most importantly state laws should contain investigation resources (staff) and funding. Enforcement efforts will fail without the resources for long complex investigations, undercover investigators and the funding to support their work.

7. Victims Bill of Rights: State laws should contain a victims bill of rights which facilitates co-operating victim’s economic rehabilitation, provides restitution and witness protection services including support to obtain certification for U and T visas. State law should prohibit prosecution of victims who cooperate with prosecution. Victim support should not be time limited but last until co-operating victims are self sufficient, up to 5 years. Victims should be provided legal assistance to sue their traffickers in civil court, for compensatory, punitive damages, attorney fees and costs of litigation. The state should be a party to all such cases to provide attorneys and to recoup its costs of prosecution.

Some advocates propose support services whether or not victims co-operate with prosecution. This is not practical or compatible with the goal of eliminating trafficking. In fact, support without cooperation in prosecuting the trafficker will encourage traffickers and increase the prevalence of trafficking.

8. Jurisdictional Accountability: Look for jurisdictional sections. Who prosecutes; how are jurisdiction and venue problems solved; who prosecutes and investigates at the local level. Trafficking statutes should not require transportation of victims across borders or state lines but the state DOJ Trafficking Unit can prosecute if venue conflicts arise. Cases can be prosecuted in state and then in fed court as racism cases are under different statutes. The federal house bill (Wilberforce) has an "in or affecting interstate commerce" jurisdictional requirement.

9. Penalties: Advocates should also review the existing state statutes. Local criminal statute’s penalties usually need to be increased. State laws are not usually the best choice for enforcement because they usually require prosecution of the victims. Most local DA’s do not have the investigative funds required to expend for the minimal sentences contained in such statutes. It is easier to prosecute the victim or the johns under local statutes and that is what they will do. Be sure to check the state trafficking statute for penalty enhancers such as force used to control victims.

III Wisconsin State Trafficking Statutes

Wisconsin enacted a state trafficking law, March 18th, 2008,titled 2007 WI Act 116.

WI Act 116, amended approximately 35 statute sections and created 17 new ones as part of WI Act 116. A through analysis is not possible in this short review of essential elements.

Briefly, using the checklist above, this is an overview of WI Act 116, which amended related state statutes and created WI Stats., 948.051, Trafficking of a Child and created WI Stats.,940.302 Human Trafficking.

(A) Wisconsin’s statute 940.302,Human Trafficking is an example of an effort to recognize the unfairness of the DOJ - MTL “means” test which requires a victim non-consent showing for conviction. Unfortunately, its' limits are recognized, not by eliminating the "means" test but by expanding the “means” traffickers use to control their victims and keep them enslaved.

WI Stats.,940.302, includes a long list of forbidden “means of” gaining consent.
“(2) (a) Except as provided in s. 948.051, whoever knowingly engages in trafficking is guilty of a Class D felony if all of the following apply:
1. One of the following applies:
a. The trafficking is for the purposes of labor or services.
b. The trafficking is for the purposes of a commercial
sex act.
2. The trafficking is done by any of the following:
a. Causing or threatening to cause bodily harm to any
b. Causing or threatening to cause financial harm to
any individual.
c. Restraining or threatening to restrain any individual.
d. Violating or threatening to violate a law.
e. Destroying, concealing, removing, confiscating,
or possessing, or threatening to destroy, conceal, remove,
confiscate, or possess, any actual or purported passport
or any other actual or purported official identification
document of any individual.
f. Extortion.
g. Fraud or deception.
h. Debt bondage.
I. Controlling any individual’s access to an addictive
controlled substance.
j. Using any scheme or pattern to cause an individual
to believe that any individual would suffer bodily harm,
financial harm, restraint, or other harm.”

(B) Definitions WI Stats., 940.302

“940.302(1) (a) “Commercial sex act” means sexual contact for which anything of value is given to, promised, or received, directly or indirectly, by any person”.

The sexual trafficking definition is limited. “Contact” will not cover strip clubs and massage pallors, especially without funds for undercover investigators.

WI Stats.,948.051 Trafficking of a child includes the language “sexually explicit performance” in addition to “commercial sex act”.

(b) Debt bondage is included but as a “means test” used for the purpose of gaining labor and services.

(c) The definition of trafficking includes the necessity to prove lack of consent:
“Trafficking” means recruiting, enticing, harboring, transporting, providing, or obtaining, or attempting to recruit, entice, harbor, transport, provide, or obtain, an individual without consent of the individual.”

( C ) Elements

“WI Stats.,940.302 (2)(a) Except as provided in s. 948.051, whoever knowingly engages in trafficking...”

Under WI Act 116, the trafficker must know; that is, have the intent to traffic. This element requires proof of intent. That benefit comes from trafficking should be enough. In any other employment situation it is the employers duty to know he is not in violation of the law. Lack of Knowledge, if the fact finder believes the defendant, should be a mitigating factor at sentencing rather than an element of the crime.

WI Stats.,948.051 Trafficking of a child includes the language “sexually explicit performance” in addition to “commercial sex act” but also also requires
“(2) Whoever benefits in any manner from a violation of sub. (1) is guilty of a Class C felony if the person knows that the benefits come from an act described in sub. (1).”

Sub 2 repeats the knowledge requirement for anyone benefitting in any manner.

Here Knowledge is a substitute for consent - although the statue seems to be a strict liability statute the prosecution must prove the trafficker knew the child was going to be used sexually.

WI Stats 940.302(3) and 948.051(3) Allow anyone who incurs injury or death,to bring a civil suits against the person who injured them, punitive damages not to exceed 3x the amount of the injury and most importantly “reasonable”attorneys fees. No mention of costs. Still without the state as a party it may be difficult to fund these cases.

(D) Other Sections of the Act

Sec 12 -19, 2007 WI Act 116, amends and allows the DA to apply to the court for an order dissolving a corporation involved in trafficking

Sec 20 creates 250.04 (14) providing funds to victims if available and if the victim co-operates until 60 days after the trial or if not co-operating for 60 days.

Sec 28 gives the court discretion to admit into evidence, after a hearing, the prior sexual history of the victim.

Sec 30 creates an affirmative defense for any victim for any act they had to do because of being trafficked - an very important provision which will encourage cooperation and is a strong reason to support the use of the trafficking statute.
Sec.51 and 52 order restitution from the convicted trafficker.

I found no training or investigation support funding in
WI Act 611. This will seriously hamper enforcement.

In conclusion, I would note that the new trafficking stats amend the WI child protection statutes (Chp. 48) and these sections of the code need careful study. WI is notorious for returning children to unsafe care givers so any sections of that code relating to the trafficking statute need to be scrutinized in detail.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

IVAWA is just another proposed monetary vehicle for attorneys and advocacy groups. Groups supporting IVAWA and VAWA expansionism are driven by greed instead of true altruism. Their hyperbolic marketing campaign for IVAWA has no limits. Don’t buy into the deception…

Many DV laws and specifically the VAWA allow immigrant women to circumvent the U.S. immigration process through false claims of domestic abuse. It can take up to ten years to secure residency legally through marriage and sometimes only six months to a year via the VAWA path. Many of the advocacy groups ( Civil Society, Casa de Esperanza, Tahari Justice Center, etc. ) which assist these immigrant women are aiding and abetting immigration fraud for financial gain in a rat race for the $1,000,000,000+ in Federal VAWA funding available each year.

VICE and Human Trafficking ( Ask Sgt. John Bandemer of the Saint Paul Police) in Saint Paul, Minnesota will often drop criminal charges ( prostitution, drug dealing, fraud, etc.) against highly paid and willing immigrant call girls ( The Likes of Ashley Dupree w/ the disgraced Elliot Spitzer ) to bring them under the wing of the VAWA with false claims of Human Trafficking. The advocacy groups are in turn funded and the Police department is funded as well. Law enforcement brings forth many “victims” of human trafficking, but very few “elusive” traffickers….

Now we have Biden coming onboard as Vice President next month and he is calling for legislation to fund 100,000 domestic violence attorneys who will continue to help perpetuate the various sorts of VAWA fraud. These politicians and advocates who support IVAWA are nothing but economic grifters playing on the emotions of people with hyped up stories of victimhood.

4:07 PM, December 05, 2008  
Blogger Greenconsciousness said...

You have to cite sections of the act if you are going to talk about the VAWA or the IVAWA. My understanding is that neither deal with trafficking. They MAY deal with domestic abuse rampant among mail order brides. I think men who try to buy economically disadvantaged foreign women with marriage offers are trying to do a form of human slavery. Once the women get here they are treated as slaves in every way. The buyers should not be protected and I am glad the women have a way out of these relationships through the VAWA. You get what you pay for when you try to buy love and or loyalty.

As for the IVAWA:

I agree with you that immigration should be restricted and borders closed but from a feminist and working class perspective.

5:05 PM, December 05, 2008  
Blogger No Blood for Hubris said...

"playing on the emotions of people with hyped up stories of victimhood."

Let's see.

That's sexist.

And -- it's crap.

Your post was good, though.

1:43 AM, December 07, 2008  

Post a Comment